Part 2:

The house became a crime scene wrapped in yellow tape, swarming with texts in white suits.

They entered through the front door, which opened with just a push.

The lock had been broken for years.

The main floor told a story.

Five purses arranged on a shelf like trophies.

Five cell phones in a row on the mantle, all different models, all dead.

Women’s clothing folded in neat piles.

Hiking boots lined up by size.

But it was the basement that made even the seasoned agents stop.

The door was reinforced steel installed recently, maybe within the last decade based on the rust patterns.

It locked from the outside.

The wood frame around it was covered in scratches, fingernail marks, some with dried blood still visible, handcarved into the frame in different handwriting at different heights.

Kayla Dawson, Brittany Cole, Amber Hutchinson, Jenna Walsh, Taylor Moss.

The basement itself was divided into two rooms.

The first held five sleeping bags on the floor, buckets in the corner, empty water bottles.

The walls were covered in scratches, calendar marks, prayers written in what looked like charcoal.

Day 43 in one spot.

Please God in another.

Mom, I’m sorry.

Near the floor.

The second room was different.

Cleaner.

A single chair bolted to the floor.

Restraints attached to the arms.

A drain in the concrete floor.

The walls here weren’t scratched.

They were too far from the chair to reach.

Ryan Dawson heard about the discovery while at work framing a house in Milbrook.

His foreman saw him go white, saw the phone slip from his hand.

They found something was all Ryan could say.

He drove the 30 m in 20 minutes, his construction truck fish tailing on the mountain curves.

The police tried to stop him at the roadblock they’d set up, but Cooper waved him through.

“Is she there?” Ryan asked.

“Is Kayla?” “We haven’t found any bodies,” Cooper said carefully.

But Ryan, they were here, all five of them.

Ryan tried to push past to get to the house, but two agents held him back.

That’s my sister’s jeep.

Her keys.

Where is she? We don’t know yet.

The FBI evidence team worked through the night.

They found DNA from all five girls, hair samples, fingerprints, blood types that matched, but no bodies, no remains.

The girls had been here, lived here for some period of time, and then gone.

Special Agent Rivera, who’d driven down from Nashville to lead the investigation, stood outside, studying the painted message.

The paint was latex, hardware store variety, applied with a brush.

But what interested her was the age.

The house had been exposed to weather for decades, but the paint was relatively fresh, maybe a year old, two at most.

Someone painted this after the girls were taken, she told Cooper years after, “Warning people away or marking territory.

” Ryan sat on the hood of Cooper’s cruiser, staring at his sister’s Jeep.

5 years of searching, of not knowing, and now this evidence they’d been held, imprisoned, but still no answers about where they were now.

Deb Pollson gave her statement for the fourth time, her voice steady but hands shaking.

The way the keys were placed, she said dead center on that table like someone wanted them to be found.

But that message, that message was telling us to stay away.

Cooper had a team photograph every inch of the house.

In one of the photos, barely visible in the basement, they found something else written in what looked like Brittany Cole’s handwriting based on comparison to her journal they’d found in her purse.

He comes at night, local accent, knows our families, knows the woods.

We trusted him.

Cooper felt his stomach turn.

Local, someone from town, someone who’d probably helped search for these girls, someone who’d comforted their families.

As the sun set over the Cherokee forest, the house gave up one more secret.

Under the loose floorboards in the basement second room, wrapped in plastic, was a journal, not written by the girls, written by someone else, someone documenting what was done to them.

The first entry was dated October 15th, 2016, 3 days after the girls vanished.

The last entry was dated December 2016, just 2 months later.

But the message on the house that had been painted in 2020 based on the paint’s weathering patterns, which meant someone had known this house and its secrets for 4 years before painting that warning.

Someone had known and kept silent while five families suffered.

The journal would need to be processed, its contents analyzed.

But one thing was already clear from the handwriting, from the methodical nature of the entries.

Whoever took these girls had help, or someone had discovered what happened and chose to hide it.

Either way, Ryan thought as he stared at that red-painted warning, someone in town knew exactly what had happened to his sister, and they were still out there.

The FBI’s evidence response team worked through the night, transforming the abandoned house into a grid of numbered squares.

each photographed, cataloged, processed.

By dawn, they had enough evidence to know this wasn’t just a crime scene.

It was a prison.

Special Agent Rivera stood in the basement’s main room, reading from her tablet.

DNA confirms all five girls were here.

Hair samples from different time periods suggest they were here for at least 2 months, possibly three.

Sheriff Cooper studied the scratch marks on the walls.

But the last journal entry was December 2016.

That’s only 2 months after they vanished.

The entries stop, but the evidence continues.

Rivera said, “Look at this.

” She led him to the corner where they had found fingernail marks in the wooden support beam.

Different heights, different angles.

The forensics team had found 23 distinct sets of scratches, suggesting extended periods of restraint.

They were moved, Rivera continued, one at a time based on the pattern.

The DNA in the second room, the one with the chair, shows they were taken there individually.

Ryan had been allowed closer to the scene, though not inside.

He stood at the basement door, staring at his sister’s name carved into the frame.

Kayla had carved it deep, like she wanted it to last, like she wanted someone to know she’d been here.

The journal found under the floorboards was being processed at the FBI lab, but Rivera had photographs of each page.

She showed them to Cooper in the mobile command unit they’d set up.

The handwriting was neat, controlled, the kind of penmanship teachers used to insist on, each entry methodical.

October 15th, 2016.

Day three.

They’re adjusting.

Kayla fights the most.

Britney cries.

Amber prays.

Jenna tries to negotiate.

Taylor hasn’t spoken.

October 22nd, 2016.

Day 10.

Established routine.

Morning feeding at 7:00.

Evening at 6:00.

Kayla tried to attack when I opened the door.

Had to discipline.

The others watched.

They’re learning.

November 1st, 2016.

Moved Britney upstairs first.

The others could hear but not see.

Important for conditioning.

She was gone 4 hours.

returned her conscious but compliant.

Amber asked what happened.

Brittany won’t say.

Cooper felt sick reading it.

This person knew what they were doing.

This wasn’t random.

No, Rivera agreed.

This was planned, systematic, and local.

Look at this entry.

November 15th, 2016.

Saw Cooper’s search team.

Two miles west.

They won’t find this place.

Been in my family since the 1940s.

Not on any current maps.

Town thinks it burned in 78.

Family property, Cooper said, someone whose family has been here for generations.

But it was the hidden pages they found that changed everything.

Brittany had managed to hide several sheets of paper inside the wall insulation written with what looked like ash mixed with water.

He knows us, knows our families, mentioned things about us that only someone from town would know.

said he watched us plan the camping trip at the diner.

Said he’s done this before, but we’re special.

We’re his finale.

Day 18.

I think he brought someone else today.

Couldn’t see who.

They argued.

The other person said, “This has to stop.

” And he said, “After this group.

” The other person sounded young.

Maybe our age.

Male.

Day 24.

The younger one came back, brought us extra water, medicine for Taylor’s infected cut.

I think he’s the son.

He looked at us like he was sorry, like he knew this was wrong, but couldn’t stop it.

Day 31.

Kayla tried to talk to the son, begged him to let us go.

He cried.

Actually cried.

Said, “I can’t.

He’s my father.

But after you, no more.

” He promised.

Rivera pulled up DMV records, property records, tax records, looking for families who’d owned land in this area since the 1940s.

The list was shorter than expected.

Only 12 families had that kind of history.

Cross reference with men who have sons aged 20 to 30.

She told her analyst.

The list narrowed to four names.

Dale Hutchkins was one of them.

Cooper knew Dale.

Everyone did.

lived off the grid mostly, but came to town for supplies, helped during searches.

His son Tommy had been more social, worked at the hardware store, dated local girls, died in a hunting accident in 2020.

Pull Tommy Hutchkins’s death certificate, Rivera ordered.

While they waited, the forensics team found something else.

In the Jeep, under years of leaves and dirt, was a single shell casing, 308 caliber, the kind used for hunting rifles.

But it was inside the vehicle under the driver’s seat.

“Someone fired a gun inside the Jeep?” Cooper asked.

“Or it fell from someone’s pocket,” Rivera suggested.

“Someone who hunts.

” The death certificate arrived electronically.

Tommy Hutchkins, aged 24, died November 15th, 2020 from a gunshot wound to the chest.

Hunting accident.

His father, Dale, had found the body.

Called it in.

No autopsy.

Small town, obvious accident, family’s wishes.

November 2020, Rivera said slowly.

And when did our paint analysis say that message was painted? Late 2020, maybe early 2021.

They looked at each other.

The timeline was forming.

More evidence emerged from the house.

In the attic, they found supplies.

Canned goods, water jugs, medical supplies.

Enough for months.

This wasn’t a temporary holding place.

Someone had planned to keep the girls here long term.

But there were also signs of disruption.

Furniture overturned not from age but from violence.

Bullet holes in one wall, patched but visible under UV light.

Blood spatter patterns suggesting a fight.

Ryan stood outside processing what he was learning.

His sister had been held here, tortured here.

But then what? Where was she now? The breakthrough came from an unexpected source.

Matt Pollson, who’d found the house, remembered something.

That paint on the message, he told Cooper.

I sold paint at Hutchinson’s Hardware for 10 years.

That specific shade of red, barn red, number 47.

We only carried at special order.

Had to order a minimum of 5 gall.

Cooper pulled the hardware store records.

In October 2020, one month before Tommy’s death, someone had ordered five gallons of barn red number 47.

The name on the order T.

Hutchkins.

Tommy had bought the paint, but the message was painted after his death.

Rivera assembled the timeline on a whiteboard.

October 2016.

Girls taken.

October December 2016.

Held in house.

Journal entries.

January 2017.

October 2020, no evidence of what happened.

October 2020, Tommy orders red paint.

November 2020, Tommy dies in hunting accident.

December 2020, message painted on house October 2021.

House discovered Tommy knew.

Rivera said he found out what his father had done.

He bought paint to mark the house, maybe to expose it, but he died before he could.

and Dale painted the message instead,” Cooper added.

To keep people away.

But there was still the question that haunted everyone.

Where were the girls? That answer came from the ground penetrating radar they brought in behind the house in what looked like undisturbed forest floor.

The radar found five anomalies.

Five patches of disturbed earth, each roughly 6 ft long, each exactly the size of a grave.

The families would need to be notified.

DNA tests would need to confirm, but everyone already knew what they’d find.

Except when they started digging, they only found four bodies.

Kayla, Amber, Jenna, Taylor, Brittany Cole wasn’t there.

And when they checked the journal again, they noticed something they’d missed.

The entries stopped in December 2016, but there was one line written in different ink, dated much later.

October 2020.

Tommy found out.

Britney talked, should have killed her with the others.

Brittany had survived, had been kept alive, and somehow she’d told Tommy the truth, which meant somewhere out there, Britney Cole might still be alive, and Dale Hutchkins was still free.

October 14th, 2016, the last normal day.

Kayla Dawson had posted the photo at 2:47 p.

m.

All five of them draped over her black jeep, laughing.

The caption read, “Digital detox weekend.

See you Monday, losers.

” Brittany Cole had commented, “If we die out there, I’m haunting you first.

” The irony wasn’t lost on anyone reading it 5 years later.

They’d left from Kayla’s parents’ house around 400 p.

m.

Ryan remembered because he’d been fixing their garage door and Kayla had honked the horn just to annoy him.

He’d flipped her off.

She’d laughed.

That was the last time he saw his sister.

The plan had been simple.

Camp at designated site number 47 in Cherokee National Forest, a spot Kayla had reserved weeks in advance.

Three nights of hiking, campfires, and friendship before they all went back to college for senior year.

Amber had even brought her camera to document everything for their last harrah before real life.

Sheriff Cooper had been on duty that Sunday when Brenda Dawson called.

The girls were supposed to be back this morning, she’d said, voiced tight with controlled panic.

Kayla’s not answering her phone.

Standard protocol was to wait 24 hours for adults, but Cooper knew these girls.

They weren’t the types to disappear.

By Sunday evening, he’d driven out to campsite number 47 himself.

Everything was wrong.

The campsite was pristine.

Five sleeping bags still rolled tight.

Cooler full of unopened food.

Amber’s expensive camera sitting on the picnic table.

No signs of struggle, but also no signs anyone had actually camped there.

Like they’d set up and immediately left or been taken.

The search started at dawn Monday.

Volunteers from town, state police, park rangers.

They found the Jeep’s tracks leaving the campsite, heading down a firebreak road that wasn’t supposed to be accessible to civilians.

The tracks went for about three miles before disappearing on rocky ground.

No jeep, no girls, nothing.

Logan Price, Britney’s boyfriend, became an immediate suspect.

He’d been texting her obsessively that weekend, angry she’d gone without him.

The texts got progressively worse.

Where are you? This is [ __ ] Brit.

I know you have signal.

Stop ignoring me.

When you get back, we’re done.

Actually, [ __ ] it.

I’m coming up there.

But Logan’s alibi was solid.

He’d been at a bar in Milbrook, gotten into a fight around midnight Saturday, spent the night in the drunk tank.

Sheriff Cooper himself had processed him.

The search expanded.

Helicopters, cadaabver dogs, infrared imaging.

The forest was vast, but they covered every trail, every ravine, every abandoned structure on the official maps.

They never found the house off the old logging road because, according to county records, it had burned down in 1978.

Dale Hutchkins had joined the search on day three, bringing his tracking expertise.

He’d pointed out game trails, suggested areas where someone might get lost.

He’d comforted Brenda Dawson when she broke down at the command post.

Girls that age, he’d said, sometimes they just need to spread their wings.

They’ll turn up.

His son Tommy had helped, too.

Quieter than his father, but dedicated.

He’d spent two weeks straight in the woods, coming back mudcovered and exhausted each night.

People said later he’d seemed haunted by the disappearance, took it personally.

Now they knew why.

By November 2016, the official search was called off.

The FBI had investigated trafficking angles, drug connections, serial predator patterns.

Nothing fit.

Five girls had simply vanished into the forest.

The families didn’t give up.

Ryan quit his job to search full-time.

He mapped every inch of the forest, marked off grids, systematic and obsessive.

He’d sleep in his truck at trail heads, wake at dawn to hike another section.

Brenda Dawson, aged 10 years in 6 months.

She kept Kayla’s room exactly as it was, bed still unmade from that last morning.

She’d sit there sometimes, holding the pillow that still smelled faintly of her daughter’s shampoo.

The Cole family hired private investigators, three different firms over two years, spending their retirement savings.

Each came to the same conclusion.

The girls had either been taken out of the area immediately or were dead in the forest.

Amber’s parents started a foundation, offered a $50,000 reward for information.

They got hundreds of tips, psychics, conspiracy theorists, people claiming to have seen the girls in Mexico, Canada, working at strip clubs in Atlanta, all dead ends.

Jenna’s family moved away after a year.

Couldn’t bear the weight of everyone’s sympathy.

The way conversations stopped when they entered rooms.

Taylor’s parents divorced.

Her father blamed her mother for letting her go.

Her mother blamed him for not insisting on GPS trackers.

The truth was neither could stand seeing their daughter’s face in the others features.

The town held vigils every October 14th.

Candles in the square, prayers, promises to never forget.

But by year three, fewer people came.

By year four, it was mostly just the families.

Dale Hutchkins came every year, stood in the back, head bowed respectfully.

The case files filled three boxes at the sheriff’s station.

Thousands of pages of interviews, dead-end leads, forensic reports that led nowhere.

Cooper read them over and over, looking for what he’d missed.

The answer had been there all along, hidden in Tommy Hutchkins behavior.

Looking back, the signs were obvious.

The way Tommy had searched the exact areas where they’d never find anything.

How he’d accidentally contaminated potential evidence scenes.

his breakdown in December 2016, which everyone attributed to exhaustion and empathy.

He’d known.

Even then, he’d known.

Cooper found Tommy’s search notes in the evidence archive.

Meticulous records of where he’d looked, but there was a pattern.

He’d carefully avoided the northeast section of the forest always had excuses.

Bear sightings, unsafe terrain, private property, the property that had supposedly burned in 1978.

There was one other thing discovered only as they reviewed old evidence with new eyes.

A gas station receipt from October 14th, 2016 found in the search of the campsite area.

Everyone assumed it had blown in from the road, but the time stamp was 8:47 p.

m.

after the girls had disappeared.

The receipt was for 5 gall of gas paid in cash.

The station was 20 m from the campsite on the opposite side of the forest.

Security footage from that night had been overwritten after 30 days, long before anyone thought to check it.

But the receipt had a partial fingerprint too smudged to match in 2016.

With modern enhancement techniques, they could try again.

Ryan stood in the FBI command unit staring at the photos of five smiling girls.

His sister front and center throwing peace signs at the camera.

So alive, so unaware of what was coming.

We’re going to find him, Rivera promised.

You found them, Ryan corrected.

Four of them anyway, but Britney might be alive.

And Dale, he stopped, unable to finish.

Dale Hutchkins had helped search for girls he’d already killed, had comforted families while their daughters bodies were buried on his property, had watched the town grieve while he kept his secret, and his son had known, had lived with that knowledge, had tried to order paint to mark the house, maybe to finally expose the truth.

Instead, Tommy had died in a hunting accident one month later.

Now they understood the real message painted on that house.

It wasn’t just a warning to stay away.

It was Dale’s confession that he’d killed his own son to keep the secret.

And somewhere out there, Dale Hutchkins was still free, possibly with Britany Cole.

The hunt was about to begin.

The hardware store still had Tommy Hutchkins employee locker in the back room, untouched since his death a year ago.

The owner, Brad Hutchinson, no relation to Amber, hadn’t had the heart to clean it out.

Tommy was a good kid, Brad told Agent Rivera as he cut the lock.

Quiet after his mom died, but reliable.

Never missed a shift until until when? October 2020.

Started calling in sick, showing up late.

Looked like hell when he did come in.

I figured it was depression.

Anniversary of those girls disappearing and all.

The locker contained work gloves, a jacket, deodorant, and a flip phone hidden behind the emergency contact form.

an old prepaid, the kind you’d buy at a gas station.

Rivera powered it on.

The battery was dead, but her tech specialist had a charger.

10 minutes later, they were scrolling through Tommy’s hidden life.

Draft messages never sent.

October 3rd, 2020.

I know what you did.

October 8th, 2020.

They deserve to be found.

October 15, 2020.

I can’t do this anymore.

Then finally, one that was sent.

October 31st, 2020, to a number that traced back to an FBI tip line.

Check the old Hutchkins property off Logging Road 47, 1940s house.

But the tip had never been investigated.

Rivera dug into the records.

The tip line had received 1,847 calls about the missing girls over four years.

This one had been classified as low priority, vague location, no specific evidence.

Tommy had tried to tell them 2 weeks before he died.

Sheriff Cooper was searching Tommy’s apartment when he found the laptop hidden in the ceiling tiles of the bathroom.

Why hide a laptop unless there was something on it you didn’t want found? The browser history painted a disturbing picture.

How to report a crime anonymously.

Witness protection program requirements.

Can you turn in your father for murder? Statute of limitations.

Tennessee murder.

If you know about a crime and don’t report it.

The searches started October 1st, 2020.

Something had happened that day to make Tommy start looking for answers.

Ryan found what that something was.

October 1st was the day Dale and Tommy went hunting together, Ryan told Rivera, showing her social media posts from locals.

Annual thing, first day of bow season.

They always went to the same area, northeast section of the forest.

Northeast section where the house was.

Cooper interviewed Tommy’s ex-girlfriend, Marissa Wells.

She worked at the diner, had dated Tommy for 2 years before they split in 2019.

The breakup was weird,” Marissa said, fidgeting with her coffee cup.

“Tommy just changed.

Became paranoid.

Said his dad was making him do things he didn’t want to do.

I thought he meant like work on the property or something.

” When did this start? Winter 2016.

Right after those girls went missing.

Tommy was never the same after that search.

Rivera pulled Tommy’s medical records.

Three ER visits between 2017 and 2020, hunting accidents each time, broken ribs, dislocated shoulder, concussion.

The attending physician had noted injuries inconsistent with stated cause, but hadn’t followed up.

Dale had been hurting his son.

Training him, punishing him, keeping him in line.

The breakthrough came from Tommy’s phone records.

On November 14th, 2020, the day before his death, he’d made 17 calls.

16 were to the same number, a burner phone that they couldn’t trace.

One was to someone unexpected, Brittany Cole’s aunt in Memphis.

The aunt, Linda Cole, answered Rivera’s call on the second ring.

“I’ve been expecting this call for a year,” she said.

According to Linda, Tommy had called her frantic.

Said Britney was alive, but not for much longer.

Said his father was cleaning up loose ends.

He’d begged her to come get Britney.

Gave an address 4782 Highway 19, an old trailer on the outskirts of town.

I drove up that night, Linda said.

But when I got there, the place was empty, burned out, still smoking.

Did you report this? To who? The nephew of the sheriff told me a missing girl was alive.

Then she wasn’t there.

They’d have thought I was crazy.

Why didn’t Tommy call the police himself? Linda was quiet for a moment.

He said his dad had ears everywhere.

Said there were others involved.

People in town who knew.

Rivera felt cold.

Others involved, not just Dale.

They searched the burned trailer site.

Fire department records showed the fire was reported November 15th, 2020 at 3:00 a.

m.

Anonymous caller.

By the time trucks arrived, it was fully engulfed.

In the ashes, forensics found bone fragments, human, female, but too damaged for DNA extraction.

Had Britney been there? Had Dale moved her and burned the evidence? Or had she never been there at all? Ryan was going through Tommy’s work schedule when he noticed something.

Tommy had requested specific days off over the years, not holidays or weekends, random Tuesdays, Thursdays.

But when mapped out, they formed a pattern.

Every day Tommy took off, someone had reported seeing the missing girls.

Credible sightings that pulled resources away from certain areas.

A girl matching Kayla’s description at a truck stop in Kentucky reported the same day Tommy was off.

Brittany supposedly spotted in Nashville.

Tommy was off that day, too.

Tommy had been creating false leads, protecting his father or protecting the girls.

Cooper found one more thing in Tommy’s apartment.

Hidden inside a cutout book was a single key.

Old-fashioned brass, the kind used for padlocks.

The key had been wrapped in paper with two words written in what looked like Britney’s handwriting.

Thank you.

The key fit nothing at the house, nothing at Dale’s property.

It was a mystery within a mystery until they checked the journal from the house again.

One entry they’d overlooked.

December 2nd, 2016 moved be to secondary site.

T will handle feeding.

Less risk.

B for Brittany.

T for Tommy.

Tommy hadn’t just known about the crimes.

He’d been forced to participate.

To feed Brittany, keep her alive.

While the others the others had been killed.

Rivera assembled the timeline.

October 2016, Tommy forced to help his father with the kidnapped girls.

December 2016, Brittany separated from others.

Tommy becomes her keeper.

2017 to 2020.

Tommy maintains the secret, creates false leads, lives with the guilt.

October 1st, 2020.

Something happens during hunting trip that breaks Tommy.

October, November, 2020.

Tommy tries to expose everything.

November 15th, 2020.

Tommy dies.

Trailer burns.

Brittany vanishes.

Sheriff Cooper stood in the FBI command unit staring at the evidence board.

Tommy tried to save her.

For four years, he kept Britney alive somehow.

Then when he tried to expose it all.

Dale killed him.

Rivera finished.

Ryan held up the key.

This opens something.

Somewhere Britney was kept.

Tommy gave her this key at some point.

But where? We’ve searched every property Dale owns.

Then we haven’t found them all.

Ryan said Dale’s been here since the 1940s.

His family owned half this county once.

There have to be other properties, other places.

As night fell, one thing was becoming clear.

Tommy Hutchkins had been both accomplice and victim.

He’d kept the secret that destroyed him.

And when he finally tried to do the right thing, his father had killed him for it.

The red paint message on the house took on new meaning.

Dale hadn’t just painted it to warn people away.

He’d painted it as a memorial to his son, the boy who couldn’t stay out, who had to be carried out.

And somewhere, if Tommy’s desperate call to Linda Cole was true, Brittany might still be alive.

They had to find Dale Hutchkins before he finished cleaning up his loose ends.

Ryan couldn’t sleep.

He sat in his apartment staring at the key from Tommy’s apartment, turning it over in his hands.

A standard brass padlock key probably 40 years old based on the wear.

The paper with Britney’s thank you was analyzed by the FBI, written in pencil, her handwriting confirmed, but no way to date it.

Sheriff Cooper had spent the night going through Tommy’s final weeks.

Phone records, bank statements, gas receipts.

The picture that emerged was of a man unraveling.

October 1st, 2020, Tommy withdrew $500 cash from ATM.

October 5th, bought five gallons of gas, paid cash.

October 8th, withdrew another $500.

October 15th, ordered the red paint from his own store.

October 20th, missed three days of work.

October 31st, sent the FBI tip.

November 10th, bought a 308 hunting rifle, the same caliber that would kill him 5 days later.

He bought his own murder weapon, Cooper told Rivera over coffee at 6 a.

m.

Or he bought it for protection, and Dale took it from him.

They’d interviewed everyone who’d seen Tommy in those final weeks.

The bartender at Murphy’s remembered him clearly.

“Kid was drinking heavy,” Jake Murphy said.

“Not normal for Tommy.

He was usually a two beer guy.

But that October, he was here every night.

Whiskey straight.

” Did he say anything? One night, maybe November 10th or 11th, he was real drunk.

Kept saying, “I can’t do it anymore.

” When I asked what, he said, “Keeping secrets.

” Then he laughed bitterlike and said, “Four years of feeding the ghost.

” Feeding the ghost, Brittany.

Ryan had gone back to the burned trailer site with ground penetrating radar.

The official investigation had been minimal.

Assumed drug lab explosion common in rural areas.

But Ryan found something they’d missed.

A root seller hidden under debris.

Inside makeshift living quarters, a cot portable toilet, stack of books, women’s clothes, and scratched into the concrete wall.

BC 2016 to 2020.

Tommy brings food Tuesdays and Fridays.

Brittany had been here for 4 years.

Rivera stood in the cellar using UV light to find more.

Blood on the cot, not much old.

Hair in the drain of a makeshift shower.

Blonde.

DNA would confirm, but they knew.

Dale kept one alive, Rivera said.

Why leverage over Tommy? Cooper suggested.

Keep helping or she dies.

Ryan found something else.

A journal hidden inside the wall insulation.

Brittany’s account of four years of captivity.

Day one.

December something, 2016.

Dale separated me from the others.

Says I’m Tommy’s responsibility now.

Tommy won’t look at me.

He knows what happened to the others.

Day 47.

Tommy brought antibiotics for my infected cut.

Risked his father’s anger.

He cried while cleaning the wound.

Said, “I’m sorry.

” over and over.

Day 186.

I asked Tommy why I’m alive.

He said his father needs him to have skin in the game.

If Tommy talks, I die.

If I escape, Tommy dies.

We’re both trapped.

Day 743.

Tommy taught me the feeding schedule.

Tuesdays and Fridays always between 2 and 4 p.

m.

when Dale is at town meetings or church.

Tommy times it perfect.

Day 1,095.

Tommy’s breaking.

Drinks before he comes now.

I can smell it.

Today he gave me this key.

Said just in case.

Won’t say what it opens.

Day 1,460.

October 2020.

Something’s changed.

Tommy says he found something at the old house.

Says he can’t do it anymore.

Says he’s going to get me out.

I’m scared.

Dale always knows.

The last entry was November 14th, 2020.

Tommy called someone.

Says help is coming.

Gave me his truck keys.

Told me to run if I hear gunshots.

Dale’s truck just pulled up.

Tommy’s going outside to talk to him.

It’s been an hour.

He hasn’t come back.

Rivera called for cadaabver dogs to search the area around the trailer.

Within an hour, they found what everyone expected, a shallow grave 200 yards into the woods.

But it wasn’t Tommy.

The dental records confirmed it was a young woman, early 20s, dead approximately one year.

That’s not Brittany, the coroner said.

This woman was Asian, probably 5’2 in tall.

Been dead since around November 2020.

Another victim, someone they didn’t even know about.

Cooper ran missing persons from 2020.

Founder Stephanie Woo, 22, disappeared from State College in September 2020.

Last seen at a gas station 50 mi from here.

Dale didn’t stop after the five, Rivera said quietly.

He kept going.

Ryan was mapping Tommy’s movements when he noticed something.

Every Tuesday and Friday, Tommy’s phone pinged off the same cell tower, not near the trailer, but 3 mi east, middle of nowhere, according to maps.

They drove out there, found nothing but forest and an old fire road.

But Ryan noticed fresh tire tracks, maybe a week old.

Someone had been here recently.

Following the tracks led to an old ranger station, abandoned since the ‘9s, locked with a newish padlock.

Ryan held up Tommy’s key.

It fit inside canned goods, water jugs, medical supplies, a cot with restraints, women’s clothes, and on the wall, a calendar.

X’s marked through dates stopping at November 14th, 2020.

But then, in different handwriting, new X’s started October 1st, 2021.

Someone had been here 3 weeks ago.

Britney’s alive, Ryan said, and Dale’s still keeping her.

They processed the station, found fingerprints, Dales, Tommy’s, and a third set.

Female, no match in the system.

But there was blood on the doorframe fresh enough to still have DNA.

While they waited for results, Rivera found something in Tommy’s bank records she’d missed.

A storage unit paid up for 5 years in advance.

paid October 8th, 2020, right after that first ATM withdrawal.

The storage unit was in the next county under a fake name.

Inside, boxes of evidence, photos of the five girls at the house, dated 2016.

Dale’s journal, the real one, describing in detail what he’d done, and a USB drive labeled insurance.

The drive contained videos Dale had recorded himself confessing, explaining his work, showing the girls while they were alive.

Ryan couldn’t watch.

Cooper made it 30 seconds before running outside to vomit.

But at the end of the last video, dated December 2nd, 2016, Dale said something crucial.

Brittany stays alive.

She’s Tommy’s project now.

Boy needs to learn the family business.

Either he becomes like me or he breaks.

Either way, I win.

Tommy had gathered all this to expose his father, had paid for the storage unit to keep it safe.

The FBI tip had probably meant to include this location, but Tommy died before he could give details.

Rivera’s phone rang.

DNA results from the ranger station.

The blood was less than 72 hours old, female, and it matched partial DNA from the burned trailer.

samples they thought were too degraded to identify.

Brittany Cole was alive.

And she’d been at that ranger station three days ago.

Dale’s keeping her on the move.

Cooper said he knows we’re close.

Ryan stood in the storage unit, surrounded by evidence of 5 years of horror.

Tommy had tried to stop it, had gathered proof, made plans, tried to save at least one person.

We need to find Dale now, Ryan said before he decides Britney’s too much of a liability.

Cooper’s phone rang.

It was dispatch.

Sheriff, we just got a 911 call.

Hiker found a woman wandering Highway 19, blonde, early 20s, asking for Sheriff Cooper by name, says her name is Brittany Cole.

They raced to the hospital, but when they arrived, the woman was gone.

The nurse said she’d panicked when a man in a baseball cap walked past her room, ran out the emergency exit.

Security footage showed her running into the woods.

The man in the baseball cap followed.

It was Dale Hutchkins.

The hunt was on, but now it was clear.

Brittany had escaped on her own using the chaos of the investigation.

And Dale was hunting her through the same woods where this all began.

Dale Hutchkins had been invisible in plain sight for 40 years.

Rivera’s team assembled his history while helicopters searched the forest for him in Britany.

Born 1959, married Linda in 1981, had Tommy in 1996.

Linda died of cancer in 2010.

That seemed to be when things changed.

First girl went missing in 2011, Rivera noted.

Hannah Morrison, 19, from Cookville, never connected to our case until now.

Dale’s work history was sporadic but strategic.

Handyman, maintenance, seasonal work, jobs that gave him access to properties, families, routines.

He’d fixed pipes in the Morrison house two weeks before Hannah vanished.

Sheriff Cooper found Dale’s actual property records, not just what he owned, but what he had access to.

His deceased brother’s hunting camp, his father-in-law’s farm, properties he maintained for outofstate owners.

17 locations total where he could move freely without anyone questioning it.

He’s got hiding spots all over this county.

Cooper said Ryan was at the hospital watching the security footage again.

Brittany had been there for exactly 12 minutes.

She’d told the nurse Dale Hutchkins killed them all.

Tell Sheriff Cooper Dale killed Tommy, too.

Then she’d seen the man in the baseball cap and ran.

The man followed her for 30 seconds, then veered off to the parking lot, got in a truck, and drove away opposite direction from where Britney ran.

“He wasn’t chasing her, Ryan realized he was hurting her into the woods, where he knew the terrain better than anyone.

The search teams found traces within hours.

Torn fabric on a branch from the hospital gown.

Footprints in mud.

Bare feet running.

Then bootprints following at a steady pace.

Not running.

Walking.

Patient.

Dale knew she couldn’t run forever.

At Dale’s house, a modest cabin 5 mi from town.

They found more evidence.

The basement was a workshop of horror.

Restraints mounted to the walls, soundproofing foam, a drain in the concrete floor, and photographs.

Dozens of girls over decades, most unidentified.

But it was the room upstairs that chilled everyone.

Tommy’s childhood bedroom preserved exactly as it had been.

Baseball trophies, school photos, Boy Scout badges, normal, except for the lock on the outside of the door.

He locked Tommy in, Cooper said, probably for years.

Inside the mattress, hidden in a slit, were pages in Tommy’s teenage handwriting.

Dad brings women here.

makes me help.

Says it’s family tradition.

Says his dad did it, too.

I want to die.

I’m 16 today.

Dad’s gift was making me bury the latest one.

Said I’m officially a man now.

I dream about telling someone, but who’d believe me? Dale Hutchkins, the helpful neighbor, the guy who volunteers at church.

Ria found financial records.

Dale had been receiving regular payments for 20 years.

$5,000 monthly deposited to an account he’d opened under his brother’s name.

The deposits came from a shell company that traced back to another shell company.

Someone was paying him.

Rivera said this wasn’t just Dale’s operation.

Ryan remembered something from Britney’s journal at the burned trailer.

She’d written about Dale talking on the phone saying, “Yes, sir, and the new batch is ready.

” Dale wasn’t the top of the chain.

He was middle management.

The break came from an unexpected source.

Stephanie Woos family had hired a private investigator when she disappeared.

He’d tracked her movements.

Found she’d been corresponding with someone online about a modeling opportunity.

The IP address traced to the library in Milbrook.

Security footage from the library September 2020.

Dale Hutchkins at a computer typing.

creating the fake modeling agency site hunting.

But in the background of one frame, someone else was visible, someone watching Dale work, someone they all recognized.

Judge Harold Mitchell, District Court, 68 years old, pillar of the community.

Cooper felt sick.

Mitchell had presided over hundreds of cases, had access to sealed records, troubled teens, vulnerable women in the system.

Pull every missing person case Mitchell had any connection to, Rivera ordered.

The list was staggering.

38 women over 20 years.

Not all would be connected, but the pattern was clear.

Young women who’d been through Mitchell’s courtroom for minor offenses, drugs, shoplifting, probation violations, the kind of women who might not be immediately missed.

They needed a warrant for Mitchell.

But they needed evidence first.

Dale’s payments weren’t enough.

They needed something concrete.

That’s when the call came in.

A ranger at tower station 4 reported someone breaking into the emergency supply shed.

The description matched Brittany.

By the time they arrived, she was gone, but she’d left a message carved into the wooden wall.

Mitchell basement.

Other girls still alive.

How did she know? Had she heard Dale on calls? Had Tommy told her? Rivera made the call.

We need a warrant for Judge Mitchell’s residence.

Now, while they waited, Ryan tracked the timeline.

Mitchell had been at the hospital the day Brittany appeared.

He was the man in the baseball cap.

He’d herded her into the woods where Dale was waiting, but Brittany had gotten away, was still getting away.

The warrant came through at 8:00 p.

m.

They moved on Mitchell’s house, a sprawling Victorian on the hill overlooking town.

Mitchell answered the door in his robe, playing confused.

This is harassment.

I’ll have your badges.

They found the basement door behind a bookshelf locked with a digital keypad.

Mitchell refused to give the code.

They brought in equipment to break it.

The smell hit them first.

Human waste.

fear, but also life.

Three women chained to walls alive.

Ashley Chen, missing since 2019.

Maria Rodriguez, missing since January 2021 and someone who shouldn’t have been there.

Taylor Moss, one of the original five.

She was alive, traumatized beyond recognition, but alive.

Dale said I was too valuable to bury, she whispered.

said the judge paid extra for college girls.

Rivera arrested Mitchell on the spot.

He said nothing except, “I want my lawyer.

” But Taylor, once she started talking, couldn’t stop.

There were others sold to other judges, lawyers, rich men.

Dale was the collector.

Mitchell was the distributor.

“There’s a whole network.

” “Where’s Brittany?” Ryan asked.

“She was here,” Taylor said.

Mitchell kept her separate, his favorite.

But two days ago, Dale came to get her.

Said the FBI was getting close.

Time to clean house.

Cooper’s radio crackled.

Search team had found something.

A body in the woods.

Ryan’s heart stopped, but it wasn’t Brittany.

It was Dale.

Shot once in the head with a 308 rifle, the same kind that killed Tommy.

He’d been dead about 6 hours.

In his pocket, a note in Britney’s handwriting, for Tommy.

For all of them.

She’d taken the rifle.

Dale had been hunting her with turned it on him.

After 5 years of captivity, Brittany Cole had become the hunter, but she was still out there, still running or hunting.

Rivera found Mitchell’s computer encrypted, but crackable.

The initial results were staggering communications with buyers across the country, a network of powerful men who ordered girls like takeout.

Dale had been their supplier for the Southeast region.

This is massive, Rivera said.

Hundreds of victims, dozens of perpetrators.

But Ryan was focused on one thing.

Finding Brittany before she disappeared completely.

She’d survived 5 years of hell, escaped, killed her captor, and revealed a nationwide trafficking ring.

She was either going to be their star witness, or she was going to vanish forever.

As nightfell, one truth was clear.

Dale Hutchkins was dead.

But his shadow stretched far beyond Milbrook.

The father’s sins had created a son who tried to save someone, and that someone had ended up saving others.

But at what cost? The manhunt for Brittany Cole had shifted.

She wasn’t a victim to be rescued anymore.

She was a witness who’d killed her captor and knew where bodies were buried, literally and figuratively.

Rivera coordinated three search teams while reviewing Mitchell’s encrypted files.

Each new folder revealed another horror.

Buyers in Atlanta, Memphis, Charlotte.

Photographs of girls being prepared for sale.

Detailed invoices like they were shipping furniture.

Brittany saw all this.

Rivera said she lived in Mitchell’s house for the past year.

She knows everything.

Ryan refused to join the official search.

Instead, he went to places Tommy used to go.

the overlook where Tommy would drink beer and think, the fishing spot where he taught local kids to cast, places where someone might feel safe.

At the fishing spot, he found her.

Brittany was sitting on the dock, feet in the water, still holding the rifle.

She looked up when she heard him approach, but didn’t run, didn’t raise the weapon.

“You’re Kayla’s brother,” she said.

Her voice was, unus to speaking freely.

Yeah, she talked about you all the time those first weeks.

Said you’d find us.

She laughed bitterly.

She was right.

Just 5 years too late.

Ryan sat down carefully, few feet away.

The FBI needs to know what you know.

They’ll find out.

Mitchell documented everything.

He was proud of it.

She stared at the water.

Do you know what the worst part was? Not the chains or the other stuff.

It was that people in town knew, had to know, and nobody said anything.

Who knew? The sheriff before Cooper.

Mitchell had photos of him with underage girls, used it as leverage.

The bank manager, who never questioned Dale’s cash deposits, the doctor who treated injuries and never reported them.

She gripped the rifle tighter.

This whole town is infected.

Ryan’s phone buzzed.

Rivera, looking for him.

He ignored it.

Tommy tried to save you.

Brittanyy’s composure cracked.

He kept me alive for 4 years, risked everything, bringing me extra food, medicine, books.

Dale made him participate to break him, but Tommy never broke.

He just got quieter.

His last call was to your aunt trying to get you out.

I know.

I was there when Dale shot him.

Her voice went flat.

Dale made me watch.

Said that’s what happens to people who betray family.

Then he moved me to Mitchell’s.

Said I was graduating to the big leagues.

She told Ryan about the last year.

Mitchell had kept her as a house manager for the other girls, made her prepare them for sale, teach them compliance.

If she refused or helped them, they were punished in front of her.

Taylor almost died twice because I tried to help her escape.

This is where he kept us first.

All five together.

She touched each name carved in the doorframe.

Kayla fought the hardest.

Jenna prayed constantly.

Amber tried to keep our spirits up.

Taylor just shut down.

Why did he keep you alive? Tommy.

When Dale decided to kill the others, Tommy begged for one.

Said he’d do anything if his dad spared one.

Dale thought it was funny.

His soft son trying to save someone, so he gave him me as a project.

She walked to the corner where they’d found the scratch marks.

This is where Kayla died.

Dale strangled her while we watched, said it was a lesson about resistance.

Ryan’s hands were fists, his sister’s last moments, and he hadn’t been there to protect her.

“She said your name at the end,” Brittany added quietly.

“Said to tell you she loved you.

” They stood in that basement for 10 minutes, silent.

Then Brittany handed him the rifle.

“I’m ready to talk to the FBI now.

” Rivera met them at the station.

The interrogation lasted 18 hours with breaks.

Brittany drew maps, named names, provided dates.

The network was vast.

Judges, politicians, police, businessmen.

Mitchell was just one node.

There’s a summit, Brittany revealed.

Continue reading….Part 1 of 2Part 2 of 2Next »